236 replies to this topic

[Vykan12]

I'd cut the swiss part to 3 rounds then.

[Tino]

Fine with me then.

[Mekkah]

Okay.

[kirsche]

I'd cut the swiss part to 3 rounds then.

Cool, I assume Mekkah opens?

[Ether]

So how about Swiss style for 4 rounds, and the 2 people with the highest scores duke it out in the finals?

In any case, let's just start the first round with 5 vs 5 and see where it goes from there.

There's one last match-up I haven't made yet.

Ether (Ilyana) vs Red Fox (Mia)
Ether (Astrid) vs Red Fox (Jill or Nephenee)

take your pic unless you want to change up your character choices.

All of those are fine with me,so Red Fox can choose.

[kirsche]

Ether (Ilyana) vs Red Fox (Mia)
Ether (Astrid) vs Red Fox (Jill or Nephenee)

Wait what? Ilyana vs Mia? They're like, 2 tiers apart. heck, I doubt Astrid can beat Jill or Nephenee can beat Astrid.

Those seem one-sided.

[Red Fox of Fire]

*Looking at the tier list because I don't know this game well enough.*

Jill vs. Astrid seems like the best one. I'm cool with that.

[Ether]

Wouldn't Ilyana vs. Neph be pretty balanced?

[kirsche]

Wouldn't Ilyana vs. Neph be pretty balanced?

Perhaps, I can see a flaw with it though.

Personally, i believe that you two should get new opponents for it unless vykan, you and ragefox are happy with said debates.

[Red Fox of Fire]

Wouldn't Ilyana vs. Neph be pretty balanced?

Considering their positions on the current tier list, that probably would.

[Ether]

Perhaps, I can see a flaw with it though.

Personally, i believe that you two should get new opponents for it unless vykan, you and ragefox are happy with said debates.

I don't see the flaw...

[Tino]

Let's not discuss that, as it may influence your debate...

[Ether]

Let's not discuss that, as it may influence your debate...

I suppose.I'm probably digging my own grave aren't I?

[Tino]

Dunno. Ilyana vs. Nephenee may be quite a fair match-up. More fair than Jill vs. Astrid, at least.

[kirsche]

I don't see the flaw...

If you don't see the flaw, then you don't see the positive.

I hope i don't sound like I'm trying to run the debate, I just don't feel comfortable with this match-up.

Edit: Whatever, let's do it.

Edited by kirsche, 29 June 2009 - 03:26 PM.

[Ether]

If you don't see the flaw, then you don't see the positive.

I hope i don't sound like I'm trying to run the debate, I just don't feel comfortable with this match-up.

Any outside opinion on the matter is welcome.

Well there you go,since you seem to be implying it's a positive for me,and I don;t know what it is,then it doesn't really effect much.Red fox said herself she wasn't all that familiar with FE9,so if it's in Neph's favour,she probably wouldn't take advantage of it either.And as Tino said,it's still probably better than the other possible matchups.
(LOL Mia vs. Mia)

[Tino]

So I guess we're all ready to rumble?

EDIT: By the way, I figured a sub-forum for the PoR forum wouldn't hurt.

Edited by Tino, 29 June 2009 - 03:40 PM.

[Vykan12]

So Ether (Ilyana) vs Red Fox (Nephenee) has been agreed upon?

EDIT: By the way, I figured a sub-forum for the PoR forum wouldn't hurt.

3 rounds of swiss + 2 semis + 1 final = 18 total match-ups, so a sub-forum wouldn't be a bad idea.

Edited by Vykan12, 29 June 2009 - 05:58 PM.

[Tino]

Yes.

So I guess we're ready to get this thing going.

[Colonel M]

Just so we're clear: the person listed first (i.e. me) will open first, correct?