236 replies to this topic

[Vykan12]

I guess we'll start with 8 participants. Pick 3 characters so we can figure out some balanced match-ups.

1. Vykan (Devdan/Brom/Tanith)
2. Cynthia (Jill/Calill/Lucia)
3. Sirius (Boyd/Makalov/Geoffrey)
4. Colonel M (Ike/Tauroneo/Haar)
5. B2BD (Kieran/Volke/Devdan)
6. Kirsche (Oscar/Janaff/Tormod)
7. Mekkah (Mist/Stefan/Shinon)
8. Tino (Tanith/Calill/Muarim)
---
9. Ether (Mia/Astrid/Ilyana)
10. Red Fox (Jill/Mia/Nephenee)

***Sign-ups are finished. Sorry for anyone who missed out

Guidelines: The debates will carry out like any other debate on this board, so read around if you're not familiar with the process. I won't impose any time constraints this time since nobody adheres to them. Just try and make timely responses, I don't want this to drag on forever. Ideally, you should be making a post every 3-5 days or something. Single elimination, so there will be 3 rounds unless I get 12-16 participants, in which case it will be 4. If there are 12 participants, there will be a wildcard round for the last 6 people who signed up unless someone has a better idea. Last thing, 5 votes decide the victor of a debate unless too many judges are missing, in which case it'll be 3.

Have fun.

Edited by Vykan12, 28 June 2009 - 03:04 PM.

[-Cynthia-]

Should we decide the number of votes per debate required to win? I think it should be either 3 or 5 judges per debate.

Hmm characters, Jill/ Callil/ Lucia. High/Mid/Low.

Edited by -Cynthia-, 27 June 2009 - 06:21 PM.

[Sirius]

Boyd, Makalov, Geoffrey.

Edited by Sirius, 27 June 2009 - 06:48 PM.

[Colonel M]

Yeah I guess.

Ike, Tauroneo, and Haar.

I'd rather not commit suicide with Bastian.

Edited by Colonel M, 27 June 2009 - 07:51 PM.

[Dat Nick]

Kieran
Volke
Devdan

as much as I can respect picking lesser used characters, wtf Lucia?

[-Cynthia-]

^Obviously only valid in low tier matchups, Rolf/Bastian/Elincia/Hawks/Shinon are probably all OK, anything above that is pushing it. Maybe i'll add someone else, since people seem afraid of low tiers.

Edited by -Cynthia-, 27 June 2009 - 10:44 PM.

[kirsche]

I'll join.

Oscar/Janaff/Largo

Edit: Upon reflection, I think Largo was a bad choice, could I swap to Tormod?

Edited by kirsche, 28 June 2009 - 02:16 AM.

[Mekkah]

okay FINE
Mist, Stefan, Shinon

[Tino]

I'll sign up.

Tanith / Muarim / Calill

[Vykan12]

We've got 8 people. If anyone else wants to join in, they better do so pretty quickly.

Some possible match-ups:

Vykan (Tanith) vs Colonel M (Ike)
Mekkah (Shinon) vs Kirsche (Janaff)
Cynthia (Calill) vs Sirius (Geoffrey)
B2BD (Volke) vs Tino (Muarim)

[kirsche]

Mekkah (Shinon) vs Kirsche (Janaff)

I'm fine with that. Should be fun.

[Ether]

I'll throw my hat in in case there is room,and I guess I'll take Mia/Astrid/Ilyana.

[Mekkah]

Yeah I'll have some of Shinon vs Janaff.

Edited by Mekkah, 28 June 2009 - 05:28 AM.

[Tino]

B2BD (Volke) vs Tino (Muarim)

Perfectly fine with me.

[-Cynthia-]

I'm fine with Calill vs. Geoffrey, we could also do Jill vs. Boyd if Sirius would prefer that.

[kirsche]

I'll throw my hat in in case there is room,and I guess I'll take Mia/Astrid/Ilyana.

That makes 9 people... One of us will have to have an extra debate if we included Ether.

I could do it, if Mekkah has no objections. Janaff vs Mia could be interesting.

[-Cynthia-]

^ How would that work?

BTW Vykan, did you look at the characters and then decide matchups, or did you put everyone in a bracketmaker and then decide? Not that I'm opposed to the first method, just curious.

Edited by -Cynthia-, 28 June 2009 - 11:42 AM.

[kirsche]

^ How would that work?

Basically, ther'd be a match between Ether and someone then the winner of that would just be placed into the tourney, which would start normally, just without the loser.

[Mekkah]

Or Ether can sub, since there's bound to be a drop-out at some point.

[kirsche]

Or Ether can sub, since there's bound to be a drop-out at some point.

What happens if there isn't? You and Vykan are pretty reliable for this stuff - you proved that in teh FE10 one, and I can't see Cynthia/Colonel M/Me dropping out either.