63 replies to this topic

[Le Communard]

You know, I've also seen the option of badges based on member affiliation groups a couple times before, and that would be cool if it could be implemented, but I'm not sure this is really the best place...

[OldMan]

You know, I've also seen the option of badges based on member affiliation groups a couple times before, and that would be cool if it could be implemented, but I'm not sure this is really the best place...

In b4 FE4THREAD

Like in FEFF?

[Le Communard]

In b4 FE4THREAD

Like in FEFF?

I think they might have done something like that, but I've seen it in other places as well. It's mostly just for amusement.

Edited by Le Communard, 10 July 2009 - 04:36 PM.

[Ike-Mike]

Male/Female/No Gender Set

Nothing more, nothing less.

[Rodykitty]

I did not vote for gender-based badges.

People can very easily set their profiles to be female, even if they are male. You may as allow everyone to mix and match these badges that are, in the end, available to everyone despite gender.

[Meteor]

It doesn't let me vote for none. They look tacky.

It was even worse when everyone had a generic badge by default, so if you absolutely must keep them, please only allow moderators to have them.

[Hikarasuman]

It doesn't let me vote for none. They look tacky.

It was even worse when everyone had a generic badge by default, so if you absolutely must keep them, please only allow moderators to have them.

Adblock them.

I'd prefer it if there were a bunch anyone could choose from.

Edited by Devil, 10 July 2009 - 05:18 PM.

[Popo]

Does anyone have a picture of the old member badges? I never saw them.

[Agro]

I voted for the selection, but then again, I was quite content without them.

[General Spoon]

If this get's cleared, I think it'll come down to a vote to select a few characters, but not all.

Neat. Everybody, remember to vote for Garret and Cecil.

Edited by Miror B., 10 July 2009 - 06:11 PM.

[NoNameAtAll]

Neat. Everybody, remember to vote for Garret and Cecil.

Haha, no.

Best way for it to be done, IMO is leaving an option for the different lords in the series.

Of course, that's just me.

[Raven]

I believe everyone working on the Serenes Emblem project should have a relevant badge.

[OldMan]

I believe everyone working on the Serenes Emblem project should have a relevant badge.

In before chain effect.

Haha, no.

Best way for it to be done, IMO is leaving an option for the different lords in the series.

Of course, that's just me.

Lords are boring.

[Le Communard]

In before chain effect.

Say, if thats going to be the case, I think everyone in the Most Refined Fraternal Lodge of Serenes Forest Secret Society Mumbo Jumbo should have one as well!

[Raven]

Whatever. Just a suggestion. A little recognition for the work we're putting into this thing. But I can take getting shot down. Please continue.

[Charlie]

Group icons would be kind of nice to have I suppose. Having more than three badges (one for each gender and one for gender not set) seems like massive overkill. In fact, just having gender-specific badges seems a tad excessive to me.

[Phoenix Wright]

Does anyone have a picture of the old member badges? I never saw them.

No, but it was just Reyson, Leanne, and Rafael. I think that topic got deleted from the hack.


I voted for selections. Variety is better.

[Superbus]

I'm always for more choice... so long as it doesn't tax the people in charge of it. I'm sure Tiena remembers full well the problem when you make things like badges or any sort of extra: you make four things, and they're great! Truly remarkable! So you've pleased 60% of the memberbase! But that other 40% isn't happy! In fact, they're downright ornery! So much so that they're going to whine, kick, scream and moan until they get what they want, and if they don't get what they want, they're going to hold their breath, take their ball, and go home!*

My advice is to give as much variety as you can within reason, and tell the 40% to go fuck off.

* In reality, the 40% crowd doesn't go anywhere. In fact, they often don't even last 24 hours before coming back. I know a few members here that justify that statement perfectly. <3

[Der Kommissar]

I'm always for more choice... so long as it doesn't tax the people in charge of it. I'm sure Tiena remembers full well the problem when you make things like badges or any sort of extra: you make four things, and they're great! Truly remarkable! So you've pleased 60% of the memberbase! But that other 40% isn't happy! In fact, they're downright ornery! So much so that they're going to whine, kick, scream and moan until they get what they want, and if they don't get what they want, they're going to hold their breath, take their ball, and go home!*

This. You wouldn't believe how whiny parts of the memberbase got when TheEnd kindly provided badges for the "select your member group badges" thing I started after becoming FESS root.

Granted, that all worked out to everyone's more-or-less satisfaction but, as they say, give a mouse a cookie...

[Masu]

Badges fer everyone sounds cool.