25 replies to this topic

[General Spoon]

Please vote for what YOU think is the best/worst in the series for this round. The round will last for about a week or so, after which I will tally the votes, and will add the top three to a list in the opening post of the next topic.

It would be nice if you nominate ideas for when I'm out of them. I'll keep track of the nominations. Please nominate only once a round.

Please remember to nominate. Also, if your vote is not for one person/thing/etc, it will be thrown out. Your vote will also be thrown out if the FE game it is from is not stated if it is needed. This is mainly to avoid confusion.

NEW RULE
If you excessively complain about the results of previous rounds, you will not be allowed to vote in these topics for a period of time that will be determined later. A list will be kept of those who will not be allowed to vote, and how many rounds until they can vote again.

Previous winners (best)
Best NPC: 1st- 3-13 Archer ; 2nd- FE10 Daein Army ; 3rd- Eltshan
Best Swordmaster: 1st- Rutger ; 2nd- Lakche ; 3rd- Shanan
Best Hair: 1st- Titania ; 2nd- Heath and Stefan (tie)
Best Non-Final Boss: 1st- Black Knight ; 2nd- Alvis and Trabant (tie)
Best Thief: 1st- Pahn ; 2nd- Matthew ; 3rd- Lifis, Volke, and Sothe (tie, FE10 Sothe can only be assumed)
Best Personal Weapon: 1st- Graphcalibur and Pugi (tie) ; 3rd - Wolf Beil
Best chapter: 1st- FE10 2-E and FE5 chapter 14 (tie) ; 3rd- FE6 Chapter 21, FE5 chapter 24x, FE5 chapter 13, FE4 chapter 5, FE5 chapter 22, FE9 chapter 13, FE9 chapter 26, FE8 Ephraim's Route chapter 11, FE10 4-5, FE9 chapter 17, and FE10 3-E (tie)
Best final chapter- 1st- FE9 ; 2nd- FE4 ; 3rd- FE5
Best final boss weapon- 1st- Judge ; 2nd- Flametongue and Loputousu (tie)
Best Personality: 1st- Levin and Kieran (tie) ; 3rd- Wallace
Best rapist or attempted rapist: 1st- Narshen ; 2nd- Oliver ; 3rd- FE10 opening movie soldiers
Best tactician: 1st- Mark ; 2nd- Soren ; 3rd- Jeigan Book 2
Best Est Archetype: 1st- Nino ; 2nd- Sara ; 3rd- Zeiss and Pelleas (tie)
Best GBA Critical animation- 1st- Lyn (Sol Katti) ; 2nd- Warrior (Axe) ; 3rd- Hector (Armads)
Best Console Critical animation- 1st- Celice 1st attack ; 2nd- FE4 Swordmaster/FE10 Black Knight (tie)
Best Epilogue- 1st- FE4 ; 2nd- FE10 ; 3rd- FE9
Best Gato Archetype- 1st- Athos/FE5 Sety (tie) ; 3rd- Galzus
Best DS critical animation- 1st- Hero (2nd attack), Swordmaster (2nd attack), Mage, Lord, Berserker (1st attack) (tie)
Best Form of Abuse- 1st-Favoritism; 2nd-FE9 BEXP Abuse; 3rd-Arena Abuse
Best FE- 1st- FE4 ; 2nd- FE5 ; 3rd- FE7 and 10 (tie)
Best Ruler: 1st- Alvis ; 2nd- Ashnard, Naesala, Caineghis, Dheginsea, Sanaki (tie)
Best Gaiden chapter: 1st- FE7 19x(HM) and FE5 21x (tie); 3rd- FE7 19xx(HM)
Best Unit: 1st- Levin!Arthur; 2nd- Ike (O_O); 3rd- Seth
Best Merc/Hero: 1st- Dieck ; 2nd- FE3 Oguma ; 3rd- Skasaher
Best Paladin (Anything that promotes into it as well): 1st- Seth and Aless (tie) ; 3rd- Titania
Best Peg Knight: 1st- FE10 Elincia ; 2nd- FE4 Fee and FE3 Book 2 Paola (tie)
Best Defense Chapter: 1st- FE10 3-13 ; 2nd- FE9 C8, FE10 2-E (tie)
Best Archer/Sniper/Marksmen: 1st- FE10 Shinon ; 2nd- FE4 Jamka, FE7 Rebecca (O_O) (tie)
Best Desert Chapter: 1st FE8 Scorched Sand ; 2nd FE10 4-3 ; 3rd FE7 Living Legend
Most Hyped: 1st Lilina ; 2nd FE10 Haar ; 3rd Nino
Best Addition to the Game Series: 1st Capture ; 2nd Weapon Triange ; 3rd Rescue and Skills (tie)
Best Lord Unit: 1st Sigurd ; 2nd FE10 Ike ; 3rd Arum and FE9 Ike (tie)
Most Generic Playable Character: 1st Ralph ; 2nd Aran ; 3rd Vika (she got exactly 1 vote)

Previous winners (worst)
Worst NPC: 1st- The three generic Caelin soldiers in FE7 ; 2nd- Lachesis' 3 Pallies and FE8 Chapter 19 Armor Knights (tie)
Worst Swordmaster: 1st- Karla ; 2nd- Shanam ; 3rd- Lucia
Worst Hair: 1st- Vaida ; 2nd- Gheb, Lowen, and Makalov (tie)
Worst Non-Final Boss: 1st- Aion ; 2nd- Toras ; 3rd Batta the Beast (6-way tie broken by a random number generator)
Worst Thief: 1st- Cath ; 2nd- Daisy ; 3rd- Ricardo
Worst Personal Weapon: 1st- FE9 Rolf's Bow ; 2nd- Sol Katti ; 3rd- Daim Thunder, Ettard, Amiti of FE9, and Caldabolg (tied)
Worst chapter: 1st- Lyn's prologue normal mode ; 2nd- FE6 chapter 14 ; 3rd- FE7 Chapter 11 (Eliwood's tale), FE10 4-1, FE10 1-5, FE4 chapter 7, and FE7 16x/17x (tie)
Worst final chapter: 1st- FE6 ; 2nd- FE10 ; 3rd- FE8
Worst final boss weapon: 1st- Dark breath ; 2nd- Nightmare ; 3rd- Ravager
Worst Personality: 1st- Aran and Vika (tie) ; 3rd- Soren, Florina, Horace and Clarine (tie)
Worst rapist or attempted rapist: 1st- Gheb ; 2nd- Oliver ; 3rd- General Lang, Eliot, Garnef, and Narshen (tie)
Worst tactician: 1st- Malledus ; 2nd- Mark ; 3rd- Soren
Worst Est archetype: 1st- Sophia ; 2nd- Est and Fiona (Tie)
Worst GBA critical animation: 1st- Great Knight ; 2nd- Thief ; 3rd- Mage, Bishop, Pirate, Soldier, and Ewan (tie)
Worst Console critical animation; 1st- FE10 Sword Armor ; 2nd- FE4 Mage Knight ; 3rd- FE4 Bow Users
Worst Epilogue: 1st- FE9 ; 2nd- FE11 ; 3rd- FE8 and FE4 (tie)
Worst Gato Archetype: 1st- Karel ; 2nd- Gato/Gotoh ; 3rd- Lehran
Worst DS critical animation: 1st- Sorceror, General (Bow), Mage (tie)
Worst Form of Abuse: 1st-Battle Save Abuse; 2nd-Arena Abuse; 3rd-RNG Stat Abuse
Worst FE: 1st- FE1 ; 2nd- FE7 and 8 (tie)
Worst Ruler: 1st- Desmond; 2nd- Dheginsea; 3rd- Mordred, Alvis, Darin, Talis, Nailah, Micaiah, Victor (7 way tie )
Worst Gaiden chapter: 1st- FE5 24x; 2nd- FE7 19xx(HM); 3rd- FE5 14x, FE6 22x, FE7 31x(HM), FE11 16x (tie)
Worst unit: 1st- Bantu; 2nd- Yuno and Lyre (tie)
Worst Merc/Hero: 1st- FEDS Samson ; 2nd- Oujay ; 3rd- FE3 Samson
Worst Paladin (Anything that promotes into it as well): 1st- Arran ; 2nd- Zealot ; 3rd- Vyland
Worst Peg Knight: 1st- FEDS Est ; 2nd- FE6 Yuno ; 3rd- Sigrun, FE9 Elincia, Florina and Syrene (tie)
Worst Defense Chapter: 1st- FE7 C15 ; 2nd- FE9 C13 ; 3rd- FE7 C18 (HM), FE7 C28 (HM), FE9 C8, FE10 1-5, FE10 3-5 (tie)
Worst Archer/Sniper/Marksmen: FE6 Wolt ; 2nd- FE5 Ronan, FE9 Rolf (tie)
Worst Desert Chapter: 1st FE6 Arcadia ; 2nd FE9 Chapter 15 ; 3rd FE10 4-3
Least Hyped: 1st Thomas ; 2nd FE10 Aran ; 3rd Eliwood ; Arum and Syrene (Tied)
Worst Addition to the Game Series: 1st Reclass ; 2nd GBA support system ; 3rd Fatigue
Worst Lord Unit: 1st Lyn ; 2nd Roy ; 3rd Micaiah
Least Generic Playable Character: 1st Levin ; 2nd Oliver ; 3rd Ardan

Nominations
Best/Worst first boss
Best/Worst Couple
Best/Worst Unlockable Character
Best/Worst Quote
Best/Wost Reference to plant-life
Best/Worst Pet (the word pet is used loosely)

Best/Worst Castle

Best: Rigel Castle. It has an incredible basement.

Worst: Nados Castle, seeing as it wasn't even built to code.

[CT075]

Because there aren't a lot of castles that stand out for me, I'll have to do this:

Best: Chalphy (The first castle in FE4)

Worst: That castle in the PoR BK fight. Because it's the stage of a hopelessly rigged fight.

EDIT: Worst: ^Castle Nados

Edited by Celice of Chalphy, 30 December 2009 - 08:00 PM.

[Candlejack]

Best: Grado Keep

Worst: Araphen Castle

[Furetchen]

Best would be the setting for the Rausten level in Sacred Stones, where like 6 Armour Knights try and hold off an entire Grado army.

Worst? I'd have to go with Camtech on that one.

EDIT: Actually, was Rausten level a palace? If so, I'm'a going for Grado Keep.

Edited by Furetchen, 29 December 2009 - 03:52 AM.

[EnjolrasMTA]

Best: Freege castle, no explanation needed.

Worst: I'm gonna go with Nados as well here

[Hero of the Golden Land]

Best: Castle Ostia

Worst: Castle Nados

[Skyward]

Best: Grado Keep. It really looks quite nice.

Worst: Nados Castle.

[Scaramanga]

Best: Grado Keep.

Worst: Nados Castle

[Mikethfc]

Best: Alpea? (from 2-E)
Worst: I don't think the name was specified but from the level in FE7 where Nils collapses and you recruit Heath and Rath

[BLS]

Best: Frelia Castle...errr Going with the Crimea Castle on this one.

Worst: Nados Castle. Lol at it being poorly built to where it actually collapses.

Edited by Black Soldier, 29 December 2009 - 12:27 PM.

[Bryan]

Best: Frelia Castle...errr Going with the Crimea Castle on this one.

Worst: Nados Castle. Lol at it being poorly built to where it actually collapses.

Crimea FTW?

Nados is worst...

[Mousefire]

best: crimea castle
worst: nados; see above

[Deliriyum]

By looks: Best: Daein Keep
Worst: idk, Nados I guess

[NinjaMonkey]

Best: Daein Keep
Worst: Castle Nados

Edited by NinjaMonkey, 29 December 2009 - 06:09 PM.

[Big Klingy]

Best: Daien Keep. It looks awesome.

Worst: Any castle in Augustria. The music gets REALLY repettetive after a while, and it's probably the only piece of music in the entire game I don't like.

[Generic Operator]

Best:Daein Keep
Worst:Nados

[Anouleth]

Best: FE9 Melior Gardens, because I think it's a super-pretty map and a really cool setting for the last battle
Worst: Jehanna Hall, because I hate all the narrow corridors, it looks ugly.

There are some other nice ones... Castle Nox, Grado Keep, FE10 Melior...

[Santino]

Best: Velthomer castle.

Worst: I have no idea what Nados is but I'll trust the general opinion.

[Doga Blockovich]

Best: Bern
Worst: Laus

[Sanger]

Best: Bern
Worst: Laus