783 replies to this topic

[Peekayell]

Credit to Elieson for coming up with the rate the unit idea.

Basically, we're gonna be rating FE10 characters according to how they perform in standard drafts.

Standard Rules:
1. This draft is for 7 players.
2. Ike, Micaiah, Sothe, Geoffrey, the Herons, the Black Knight, and Lehran are free for all to use.
3. The drafting order is reversed for the last round of picks.
4. Haar is banned from drafting.
5. The game will be played on Normal Mode.
6. No transfers.

Rules:
1. Undrafted units may recruit characters, Rescue and Shove/Smite undrafted characters and NPCs, trade, Escape, and transfer items/skills between teams.
2. Undrafted units may not do anything not listed above, including but not limited to meatshielding, building Supports, Shoving/Smiting undrafted characters, opening Doors and Chests, finding hidden items, Arriving, and giving Blood Tide/Night Tide/White Pool bonuses.
3. Allied and Other units may do as they please without penalty.

Penalties:
1. Undrafted units have a 4 turn penalty, per unit per chapter (1-6 counts as 2 chapters, and 4-E counts as 5 chapters).

Exceptions:
1. One of Edward or Nolan is free for each of 1-P, 1-1 and 1-2.
2. Volug is free for 1-5.
3. Elincia, Marcia and Nealuchi are free for 2-P
4. Nephenee and Brom are free for 2-1.
5. One undrafted, non-Lucia unit is free for 2-2.
6. One undrafted, 7 move unit is free for 3-1.
7. One undrafted, 6 move unit is free for 3-3.

Day 1: Micaiah- 7.5
Day 2: Edward- 9.1
Day 3: Leonardo- 2.6
Day 4: Nolan- 9.1
Day 5: Laura- 6.0
Day 6: Sothe- 9.6
Day 7: Ilyana- 7.2
Day 8: Aran- 7.6
Day 9: Meg- 3.8
Day 10: Volug- 8.0
Day 11: Jill- 8.8
Day 12: Zihark- 8.1
Day 13: Tauroneo- 4.6
Day 14: Fiona- 1.6
Day 15: Tormod- 4.0
Day 16: Muarim- 3.8
Day 17: Vika- 3.0
Day 18: Nailah- 7.6
Day 19: Rafiel- 9.5
Day 20: Black Knight- 5.6
Day 21: Elincia- 7.4
Day 22: Marcia- 7.9
Day 23: Leanne- 8.5
Day 24: Nealuchi- 7
Day 25: Haar- 10
Day 26: Nephenee- 8.5
Day 27: Brom- 4.9
Day 28: Heather- 5.6
Day 29: Lucia- 4.9
Day 30: Mordecai- 6.7
Day 31: Lethe- 4.4
Day 32: Geofffrey- 4.0
Day 33: Kieran- 5.4
Day 34: Astrid- 3.6
Day 35: Makalov- 5.0
Day 36: Danved- 4.4
Day 37: Calill- 6.2
Day 38: Ike- 9.8
Day 39: Titania- 9.8
Day 40: Soren- 7.0
Day 41: Mist- 1.8
Day 42: Rolf- 5.8
Day 43: Boyd- 8.9
Day 44: Oscar- 8.8
Day 45: Shinon- 7.4
Day 46: Gatrie- 7.8
Day 47: Rhys- 5.75
Day 48: Mia- 7.5
Day 49: Ranulf- 6.8
Day 50: Kyza- 3.3
Day 51: Lyre- 1.8
Day 52: Reyson- 8.8
Day 53: Janaff- 7.2
Day 54: Ulki- 6.9
Day 55: Sigrun- 6.25
Day 56: Tanith- 7.6
Day 57: Skrimir- 6.6
Day 58: Naesala- 7.1
Day 59: Sanaki- 4.6
Day 60: Tibarn- 7.6
Day 61: Pelleas- 2.9
Day 62: Stefan- 2.7
Day 63: Oliver- 0.9
Day 64: Bastian- 1.7
Day 65: Fireman- 2.3
Day 66: Caineghis- 4.8
Day 67: Giffca- 4.2
Day 68: Kurthnaga- 1.1
Day 69: Ena- 2.25.
Day 70: Renning-1.75
Day 71: Nasir- 2.75
Day 72: Gareth- 1.6
Day 73: Lehran-

1 Haar
2 Ike/Titania
4 Sothe
5 Rafiel
6 Edward/Nolan
8 Boyd
9 Jill/Oscar/Reyson
12 Leanne/Nephenee
14 Zihark
15 Volug
16 Marcia
17 Gatrie
18 Aran/Nailah/Tanith
21 Micaiah/Mia
23 Elincia/Shinon
25 Ilyana/Janaff
27 Naesala
28 Nealuchi/Soren
30 Ulki
31 Ranulf
32 Mordecai
33 Skrimir
34 Sigrun
35 Calill
36 Laura
37 Rolf
38 Rhys
39 Black Knight/Heather
41 Kieran
42 Makalov
43 Brom/Lucia
45 Tauroneo
46 Lethe/Danved
48 Tormod/Geoffrey
50 Meg/Muarim
52 Astrid
53 Kyza
54 Vika
55 Leonardo
56 Mist/Lyre
58 Fiona

Edited by Balcerzak, 14 March 2012 - 09:31 PM.

[Lightli]

8/10. Free, great at healing, and Thanibombing make her a good unit.

[Aquaman]

8/10.
Can nuke high-def enemies.
Insta A with Sothe.
Also, Sacrifice may be worth something......I guess getting down to wrath/resolve activation could count..
Also, you forgot to mention high magic+healing.

Cons
Speed growth is .
Also, she has the durability of wet tissue paper that's been soaked for hours.

[Juliet]

8.

She can 1HKO Knights and Cavaliers as long as you go on training her a bit. She can 2HKO reliably. She can heal from long/range and stuff and shes free.

[Integrity]

She was amazing in one draft I was in, but that was EM and I abused her stats a little bit early on. I'll go with 6/10.

EDIT: @Soul, most prominently, if we're doing free units I'm still counting them on the same level as draftees. Free means nothing.

Edited by Integrity, 01 January 2012 - 02:50 PM.

[Juliet]

Take note Im not counting that as a point for her score, its just great she has all those benefits when shes free. Shes the reason I dont ever need a healer for Part 3.

[Peekayell]

Take note Im not counting that as a point for her score, its just great she has all those benefits when shes free. Shes the reason I dont ever need a healer for Part 3.

Or Part 4 for that matter. Shes also got Rescue in endgame without costing a deployment slot.

[Red Fox of Fire]

It's kind of hard to score free characters, I think. Usually I'd think in terms of "Why would I want to draft this unit?" but I obviously can't with free units. But I don't want "she's free" to be a point in her favor for her score, either. So...

7/10. Powerful offensively, but awful durability means she'll always need support until later when she can use Resolve to hold her own, if that ever even happens. Fairly poor movement, but the maps she's in usually aren't very move-centric, either, so it doesn't hurt her too much. Also very nice to have around as support for Sothe, who will almost always be doing most of the heavy lifting for all of part 1 and some of part 3.

[CR-S01]

8/10

Her with resolve is amazing, plus she's free. Sure, she gets 2HKO'd by most things throughout the game, but that's why resolve works so well on her. Resolvecaiah can also ORKO the laguz in 3-6 with resolve and with Sothe support and a thicket she won't get hit much after she's in resolve range. She makes my life easier in the desert chapter when I don't have a flier drafted. She can start pulling her weight (which admittedly is not very much, since it's only like 5) in 1-6-1 if she can take at least one hit and clear the armors up top with resolve active. In 1-8, she can clear out the left side of the map. She 4-turns 1-9. And more. So yeah, I love Resolvecaiah.

[Quintessence]

7/10

Good offense, but easily beaten if there's nothing to support her (Sothe (support/guard), Resolve).

Edited by Quintessence, 01 January 2012 - 06:49 PM.

[Aquaman]

She's Rhys 2.0.
Better growths, thani, and is free.

[Stark]

I think she's worth a solid 8/10. Thani and auto A support are big pluses. Speed is a downer, but resolve makes her usable if frustratingly reliant on luck. Also, as a side note, I don't think I have ever seen Sothe activate guard and protect her.

[Kopfjager]

7.5 out of 10.

Good offense, crappy defense, but is free, can heal, and thanibomb.

To be fair, her main selling point to me is that she's FREE.

[Bluedoom]

8/10

I wouldve rated her otherwise in Hard Mode. >.<

[Peekayell]

Micaiah's average is 7.5.

Day 2: Edward

Pros: Great availability. Good offensive growths. Wrath. Resolve + Wrath makes an amazing combination on him. Can use Caladbolg starting in 3-6 for even better dodge and offense. Drafting him can save 3 turns in 1-4 thanks to his great offense. Abundant BEXP allows him to promote as soon as 1-7 in NM.

Cons: Bad durability. Bases are inadequate for a level 4 myrmidon. Sword lock means inferior 1-2 range.

I give him a 9.5/10

[Integrity]

I'm going to give him a 9, despite the fact that I've never actually had him in a draft.

In other words: my advice is untainted by experience.

[Red Fox of Fire]

9/10. Great availability and growths/stats. Lack of good 1-2 range and low movement hurts a bit, though.

[Aquaman]

9/10
Great availibility
Growths

Endgame.
And mass bexp means promotion by even 1-6.
Wrath-Resolve-Vantage
And Caladbolg
Con
Durability
Bases
Lol Wind Edges for most of game.

And I could say that Zihark and Mia exist, but this is a mass rating of edward, not those 2

Edited by The Creeper, 02 January 2012 - 02:59 PM.

[Juliet]

9.

Edward is amazing.

[Quintessence]

9/10

His bases suck but his growths give him a boost, specially since he's usable from the very first chapter of Part 1. Innate Wrath is a plus. 1-2 range swords also suck but they're still useful, somehow. Quite good performance.