783 replies to this topic

[Rapier]

How can you guys give 9 to Edward? He's always 2HKO. o_o

Edited by Rapier, 02 January 2012 - 03:55 PM.

[Integrity]

You know we're talking about NM, right? And in a draft, where Edward gets every XP ever, the only chapter he's 2HKOd in is 1-P.

[Red Fox of Fire]

Edward is not even 2HKOd in 1-P. Not even in HM iirc.

But yeah, being fed most of the experience with those growths means he really doesn't have any significant problems statistically.

[Peekayell]

Hes 5HKO'd in 1-P actually. He gets 2HKO'd only in 1-1 if he didnt proc def/hp. That is easily solved with the dracoshield though. Which he will probably get in a draft setting.

[Integrity]

Is he? I had images of him dropping to Wrath health after 2 hits, which would suggest a 3HKO as opposed to the 2HKO I suggested.

On the other hand, my points is just being further proven - my "facts" aside.

[Peekayell]

Note that was off the top of my head. Ive done 1-P so many times now in NM and im 90% sure hes 5HKO'd there. In HM, hes like 3-4HKO'd there. He may be 3HKO'd in 1-1 instead of 2HKO'd in NM not sure.

[Soul]

He takes 6 Dmg from most enemies at 1-P on his 18 HP. Do the math.

[Peekayell]

^19 HP. The bandits near the boss in HM do 7 damage. So he CAN be 3HKO'd but mostly hes 4HKO'd in HM 1-P.

Anyway, lets get back on topic. HM has no relevance in this xD.

Edited by PKL, 02 January 2012 - 04:39 PM.

[CR-S01]

I'd give him a 8.5/10. I've only had him once and that was when he was sharing the spotlight with Aran, but he doubled everything and promoted really early.

[Rapier]

You know we're talking about NM, right? And in a draft, where Edward gets every XP ever, the only chapter he's 2HKOd in is 1-P.

Meh. I wouldn't be surprised anymore if someone came and said that Fiona and Leonardo pwn.

[Red Fox of Fire]

Meh. I wouldn't be surprised anymore if someone came and said that Fiona and Leonardo pwn.

Fiona's not great but not bad (in this specific scenario). Leonardo still sucks.

[Aquaman]

Drafts in fe9/fe10 mean bexp dumpage.

Fionas good growths+boosters+forges can do something come p4.

Leo gets Lughnasadh p3
And double bow endgame.

I'd call Astrid a good mid-late pick
But that's just me.

Oh, and Edward has kinda bad durability.
As opposed to Nolan/Volug/Zihark/Jill.
S
Aside from 1-P exp, what does he do that Nolan doesn't .
Aside from doubling slightly sooner.

[Peekayell]

Edward can 4 turn 1-4. Nolan can also do it but he requires crits or getting insanely speed blessed. Most Nolan drafters Ive seen get a 5 turn there. But yeah, both are extremely similar. Nolan has an edge with hand axes and better durability. While Eddie doubles earlier and Wrath shenanigans.

[CR-S01]

He can 4 turn it? How?

[Peekayell]

He can 4 turn it? How?

Sothe takes the west. Eddie takes the east. Assuming you forge an Iron Sword with Max MT and Crit, he has a very good chance of 1RKOing everything. Even the boss because he likes to be dumb and approach without being able to transform. If anything survives, there is always Micaiah :p. Though a 4 turn means skipping the Seraph Robe which might help Micaiah.

[Soul]

wat

Edward shouldnt be going to the East. That is too risky. Just have him stay South and have enemies come to him. Sothe should take out the rest of the enemies coming for him from both sides at the top.

[Bluedoom]

Edward gets... 10/10. Cause he's boss and my favourite. That and he rips shit once he promotes and continues to rip through enemies forever.

[Soul]

I wonder what score youll give Haar then...

[Integrity]

Also 10/10?

[Soul]

Haar flies. Haar is invincible right off the bat. He can actually kill things from range. That is a reason for a 10.