24 replies to this topic

[Peekayell]

Dat Rules (borrowed/stolen from Integrity)
- Ratings are assumed to be on Hard Mode (JP Maniac).
- Votes need some explanation regarding their gameplay performance to be counted. If somebody else said what you want to already, quote them explicitly.
+/- ≤1 point extra regarding personality/appearance is encouraged, but no more. If you exercise your bias privileges, please do so explicitly.
- Numerical votes out of 10, or something proportional to it. Make it easy to calculate for my sake.
- Every ranking phase ends whenever I get out of bed, between 0700 and 0800 EST. Do the math for your timezone, Brits.
- I will insist you do not use the "Not X" reason on any character, where X is another unit. If you do, your vote will be thrown out.
- "Recruits X" or "takes you to X chapter" arguments are explicitly banned. C'mon, people, this shouldn't need to be a rule. That's not gameplay performance.
- Assume that the character in question is being recruited.
- Similar to the "Recruits X" rule, do not use "she brings a Savior to the team" as an argument.
- BEXP is free to be used in any quantity on any character.
- Skills can be reassigned freely.
- No transfers.
- I withhold the privilege to tell you your rating is bogus and demand you revise it if it breaks any of the above. I will not throw out votes anonymously, you will be informed and given a chance to revise.

Averages:
Meg: 1.341
Leonardo: 2.531
Ilyana: 3.75
Tauroneo: 4.5
Aran: 4.926
Laura: 5.139
Edward: 6.316
Micaiah: 6.5
Zihark: 7.44
Jill: 8.46
Volug: 8.875
Sothe: 8.938
Nolan: 9.069

[Agro]

0/10 - she can't do anything. Something possessed me to train her up, once, and I was actually well-rewarded - her growths are really nice and well suited for her class's caps, and her innate Imbue is really nice after she starts capping stuff. But getting there was an absolute bitch and she had to be babied all the way until the Tower. Still, +1 bias from me because I enjoy babying her and taking advantage of those growths for 1/10.

Edit: I'd forgotten about her Earth affinity; she can pull shenanigans with Volug and/or Nolan in Part 3 if the two aren't supporting if other already, so it's a 2/10 from me.

Edited by Agro, 18 April 2012 - 05:41 PM.

[Merry Sioux]

Funnily enough the only thing that's bad about Fiona are her stats

1/10 for rescue shenanigan's

[Zman]

She has a horse, which instantly makes her more useful than Meg. She can't do much aside from rescuing though.

1/10

[Aquaman]

DB Est done wrong.

But, nice class, looks OK, and has some long term potential if we're willing to use her.

Unlike Meg.

1 for the mount and +1 for bias.

2/10< watch this one be the highest rating in here!

[Florina Stark]

Fiona, steward of Marado and daughter of one of the former Four Riders of Daein.

ooook...

Pros:
Good skills!
Mounted.
Growths are pretty nice.
Earth Affinity.

Cons:

Joins at a bad time.
Bases are rather terrible.
Base level is rather unpleasant.
A veritable asspain to train.

Fiona...The unit everyone hates but Florina adores. I actually dont care for units like this but Fiona won a soft spot in my heart. Shes the only horsie unit the DB gets. The downside is that her bases are shitastic. Her skill and strength bases are morbidly low. She might need to eat a Secret Book and an Energy Drop to get going. Shes gonna get probably ORKO'd by junk if left at her bases on her joining chapter. She will need BEXP to not die. Training her usually means 1-E turn spam up the wazzwazz to take advantage of her good growths. Shes got innate Savior and Imbue. Savior means rescue fun. Imbue means she can heal damage she takes because shes got a pretty...interesting...magic growth. Fiona's earth affinity means...well yeah. Shes actually quite good when trained, but it takes a great deal of patience, turn abusing, resources, and effort to get her to that point. If she is trained up, her part 3 is ok and her part 4 is kinda awesome. But so many people would never be arsed to do that because they take one look at Fiona and her joining perdicament and go "Ahh HELL NAW!" Shes actually downright pointless in Hard Mode save for the skills she brings. Sad story really.

1/10 (i dont do zeros) My bias score is actually stupidly high at 7/10. But ignore that.

[BLS]

She's a horrible unit. Underleveled, weak bases (even for her base level), comes late in Part 1, etc, etc.

0.5/10. No bias points.

[ポーラ]

Shit.

0.5/10

Edited by リンダ, 20 May 2012 - 07:38 AM.

[Darros]

lolololololololololololololololololololololololol

I think IS was seriously trolling when they decided to give her saviour. Seriously, what a useless skill on Fiona when she dies when things look at her funny. And she's worse than the rest of the DB, because not only does she die easily, she can't hit either! And when she does, you better be used to hearing some tinking! She joins underleveled with weak bases for her level, usually underleveled people have good bases for their level!

Fiona, doing it wrong since 2007.

.5/10

[CR-S01]

She would've been good in another game, really. Sucks that she chose to be in this one.

She can rescue in 1-7 and I guess she can kind of rescue for 1-E, and then she can chip at gauge/finish stuff off in 3-6. Her growths are actually kind of decent, but her bases suck ass and there's not much time to train her so no point really.

1/10

[Anouleth]

I've heard she can be useful in drafts?

1/10

[Agro]

AH I forgot about her Earth affinity, readjusting my vote.

[Peekayell]

I've heard she can be useful in drafts? 1/10

Not really...she can be BEXP'd to 3rd tier in 4-2, but shes too reliant on adept and javelin forges because BEXP fiona completely ignores her str...:/.

[Melonhead]

Rant time :D

To make you guys not have to read it, it's a
0/10.

Spoiler ()

Fiona. Oh my god. I thougt meg was the worst unit in the DB, until this... ridiculous blue armored THING came along. REALLY?!?! SHE HAS HORRIBLE BASES, TERRIBLE STARTING LEVEL, ABMYSAL CLASS (7 OTHER
PALADINS. 7 OF THEM!!!) AGHH!! IS tried to give her something good, with imbue and savior. SHE IS THE ONE THAT NEEDS TO BE RESCUED!! WHAT WERE THEY THINKING!! AND
IMBUE?! SHE IS GONNA BE ORKO'D ANYWAY!!! WTF?! GIVE IT TO SOMEONE ELSE!! HER ONLY USE IS TO SEE HER GET
MAULED BY A PART 4 BOSS!! COME ON!! THE ONLY THING SHE COULD DO DECENT IS BE BAD!! YOU COULD USE
HER AS A CONVOY, CARRYING STUFF AROUND FOR OTHER PEOPLE, B-OH YEAH!! THEY ALREADY
HAVE THAT!! FIONA IS A WORTHLESS PIECE OF GARBAGE! IT'S ALMOST
IMPOSSIBLE FOR HER TO PROMOTE WITHOUT BEXP!!! SHE HAS TERRIBLE AVALIBILITY, TOO. **** YOU, FIONA!!!!!!

ok, I'm done. Sorry if that broke any rules.

Edited by Melonhead215, 18 April 2012 - 06:41 PM.

[Silent Mercenary]

Pros:
+Good affinity and 3 possible Earth buddies in the DB
+Good endgame
+Imbue, for healing those very common injuries she will be getting until she can avoid well
+Savior, although she won't take much advantage of it and it would most likely be taken away from her because...

Cons:
-4 for her HORRIBLE joining time, not only is it late, but the chapter terrain is completely against her for 4 out of her first 5 chapters (3 indoor maps and 1 swamp), leaving only the 3-12 mountain slide for her to move freely and like a normal mounted unit. Add to that, the fact she's unavailable for the chapter she would have been needed the most.
-2 for both low starting level and low bases
-2 Not easy to train, specially on hard mode. Training her is beyond babying and more like giving her all the BExp and kills you can just to make her decent. Although, 1-E has Physic priests she could train on, we are considering the no-Battle-saves Hard mode where being able to do this is unreliable, tedious and luck-based.
-.25 for C Lance rank at this point in the game, meaning she can't use up Tauroneo's Silver Lance and needs an Iron Lance forge. Also, she can't use Discipline like Aran to raise it fast because of that 5 capacity.
I really think IS wanted to make her the worst unit in this game because of all these factors conveniently against her.

+.5 +.25 for her horse that sees little use aside Canto on her first chapters
+.5 Earth Affinity

2.5/10 because she has a few redeeming qualities. I like the girl and would like to see more of her, but she will get no bias points from me.

I started training her once but she kept missing most of the time. I'll use her on an Easy run I have planned soon, where she'll get a forged lance and almost exclusive access to all of 1-7's CExp/BExp.

Edited by Silent Mercenary, 18 April 2012 - 07:29 PM.

[Anouleth]

Not really...she can be BEXP'd to 3rd tier in 4-2, but shes too reliant on adept and javelin forges because BEXP fiona completely ignores her str...:/.

I didn't say she was very useful, but even just being an extra pair of hands in Part 1 and Part 3 can be useful. She can carry Micaiah, for example.

[Eail]

Absolute crap, only worse unit in the game is Lyre.

1/10


And that's just because of the Horse

Edited by Eail, 18 April 2012 - 09:57 PM.

[RNG Princess]

Fiona is not totally bad for a bottom tiered unit because she's not totally useless ^^'. In hard mode she's easier to train than Meg because of canto.

EM: 6/10
NM: 5/10
HM: 2/10

I find her useful for ferrying in HM, she can rescue+drop through several maps or javelin gauge in 3-6. She's not worth training in HM at all and won't offer supports quick but if babied she won't have forever trouble like Meg even though both are costly at least if Fio reaches her caps she'll eventually do something good and has no move issues. I think all the DB's are useful even if only a little for ledge blocking. Using Fiona in 1-7 lets my Jill or Volug fight freely because Fiona does the rescue dropping and the other scrubs can help with shoving Miccy and in Part 3 she can build defensive forces by rescue dropping generals or help block more than 1 ledge past that she'll do nothing unless she was trained in combat. In NM/EM she's fixable because of plentiful BEXP but in that mode Meg is better than her.

I'll give Fiona a generous 4/10 3/10

4 is going too high ^^'

Edited by Queen_Emelina, 18 April 2012 - 10:06 PM.

[Silith]

So we managed to keep Fiona alive in 1-6-2 (thank you Tauroneo for being our bomb to drop). Now she's playable.

In 1-7 she gets reduced movement because it's indoors. To make things worse the best route goes over ledges and horses can't get up them. He combat is horribad unless you put like all resources you have on her including the 3 boosters and a forge. Without them her Steel lance will weigh her down and give her crappy hit rates which do almost no damage.

In 1-8 she is gone? Grrrrrrrreat!

1-F. More indoor with ledges limiting her to a single route guarded by heavily armored enemies. To make thigns worse the enemies are not only stronger themselves they now get 3 authority stars. Fiona has a hard time.

3-6. I hope you didn't expect to get off the starting isle. She cannot move in the swamp so she's forced to sit at the edge at best. (well the best would be behind your tank line throwing javelins or something) Laguz eat her even with the C-rank support she could have by now. (technically B is possible but that would mean lots of turns on 1-7 AND 1-F).

In the unlikely case you get her to the late game Her earth affinity and stats are pretty nice. 34 Speed is that key point to double Dheginsea and Ashera's Shield. Getting there is the problem.

3/10

[Onmi]

Fiona blows, in Normal Mode she doesn't have the bases to keep up with your team from her joining chapter LET ALONE Hard Mode, She's an out and out growth unit except there's never a good time for her to grow, since everything kills her and none of the maps are suited for her. Sure if she's levelled up she can wind up being a Paladin worthy of the end game but... why bother?

Paladins aren't nearly as amazing in RD as they were in PoR, she loses out on Axes and instead gains fucking bows, and to even invest the resources to make her worthwhile is like shoving your dick into a blender and washing your testicles get slices up by the blades.

0/10ing as hard as I can.

She does have a super-fast relationship growth with Danved though, wonder what's up with that