294 replies to this topic

[Ether]

hahahaha fuckin' called it

'Twasn't all that hard to figure out. Naw man, what I did was I requested to be mafia, where people would think I would request to be town so I wouldn't be a target, man. Brad just heard me wrong.

[Balcerzak]

I also apologize to Bal since I was ~kinda a dick~ about my suspicions on him.

Also, apologies to Bal, I was kinda a bit of a dick this game as well. Soz. :(

Don't worry mans, if I can't take the heat, I wouldn't be playing. You were for the most part legit and on the up-and-up. I made some questionable plays, and you caught them. That's mafia.

We found out Manix was Bomb Night 2 and we knew Bal was Watcher from Day 1.

I knew I should have stuck with my self-watch N1...

[Paperblade]

lol, when they inspected you I was like "Hmm maybe I shouldn't have pointed out to Bal that kills were active"

[Aere]

I think I did... better. Haha. Dunno what to say.

[Solais]

It did look like I was going to be lynched, but none of the reasoning I saw for it really made a whole lot of sense. Then again my first mafia game I found 2 mafia soon as a town cop and started pinning them for flaky shit too, just because I knew they were mafia but didn't have a lot to go on.

[Witch]

Made sense to me. You blatantly voted town (Ether) over scum (Psych) despite grouping in Psych with the scummy folks and chastising Psych without providing a reason Ether was scummier that wasn't bullshit.

If you were to argue that you'd do the same thing as town then I'd just argue that you need to be policy vigged more often vOv

[Witch]

like... yeah Ether's a better player than a lot of the people you called out, but that doesn't excuse just voting him instead of bothering to prioritize and figure out The Scummiest, since town's job is to find scum even when everybody looks terrible. It seemed like an excuse to be voting a townie over Psych, who you implied you were poking at but were not actually aggressing

this could alternately be chalked up to laziness instead of scumminess, but that's what the policy vig solution is for

[Witch]

I will admit that the other more minor things I brought up about you (like, "obviam was calling me town to frame me once he flips scum!!!!!!!") were basically non-conclusive fluff points to make people listen to me.

itslikeimreallykelseygreen

Edited by Prims, 13 May 2012 - 12:39 AM.

[Helios]

Obviam was next on my scumdar for reasons already mentioned, but I really thought for a while that Bizz was town over Aere. But, at least for me, it's hard to tell when she's town or scum because of her...unique...playstyle lol.

[Witch]

I had this metatell where Levity was probably scum because she obviously cared about how people perceived her and was going out of her way to make her reads sound very logical and justified. Usually when she thinks some dude is town she's all "what the fuck are you guys doing don't lynch ___" but leaves it at that until people get upset and press her.

then i figured meta tells are stupid and dropped it ;_;

Edited by Prims, 13 May 2012 - 12:57 AM.

[Leder]

Thanks for dropping it, since I'm trying to change my playstyle overall. No one ever listens to me because I'm either too flaky or my arguments "aren't logical enough." I've been talking about this to Brad and told him that next game after this one I'll probably be playing very differently than usual, regardless of my alignment.

Although I will admit I was watching myself this game since I tend to fuck up unconsciously; I still did remember to throw in the token "don't lynch Ether" because from my perspective he was obvtown anyway, and so was Helios.

[Witch]

Well, there's nothing wrong with telling people not to lynch your town reads. They just tend to get angry if you don't explain why their preferred lynch target is bad.

[Leder]

When I get a surefire town read, they become my anchor in the game and when they end up getting lynched for bad reasons/die somehow, I get sad and lose ~confidence~ for the rest of the game.

[Liquid Snake]

And I kinda feel bad for lynching Psych D1, cuz he's the one who wanted to play and all.

No what the hell that was the best part of the game.

The only way it could be better is if he wasn't mafia and died N1.

[Solais]

If you were to argue that you'd do the same thing as town then I'd just argue that you need to be policy vigged more often vOv

It is and you're an idiot.

"obviam was calling me town to frame me once he flips scum!!!!!!!"

At least you're consistent, even if it's about being wrong. I called you "more town than the others" because that was how you appeared.

Also, the most suspicious thing about Bizz was the fact that she kept mentioning me all the damn time and just generally making it obvious that she was trying to (not so) discreetly urge a team member to play differently (wasn't going to happen).

And I kinda feel bad for lynching Psych D1, cuz he's the one who wanted to play and all.

I don't remember what the reasons you had for voting him were, but I remember when you posted him I thought "yeah that sounds like a pretty accurate summary and I would be voting him too if I were town". All prior to that I wanted to vote for Bizz because it made the most sense as far as if I were a townie after she pulled away from everyone else (until then it really was a 4+ way tie that I wasn't about to wrack my brain over).