49 replies to this topic

[Dinfinitysymbolfina]

Dat Rules (borrowed/stolen from Integrity)
- Ratings are assumed to be on Hard Mode (JP Maniac). And only hard mode!
- Votes need some explanation regarding their gameplay performance to be counted. If somebody else said what you want to already, quote them explicitly.
+/- ≤1 point extra regarding personality/appearance is encouraged, but no more. If you exercise your bias privileges, please do so explicitly.
- Numerical votes out of 10, or something proportional to it. Make it easy to calculate for my sake.
- Every ranking phase ends when the next RTU thread is posted (at this point, it's hard to tell).
- I will insist you do not use the "Not X" reason on any character, where X is another unit. If you do, your vote will be thrown out.
- "Recruits X" or "takes you to X chapter" or "Gives you Bronze Sword" arguments are explicitly banned. C'mon, people, this shouldn't need to be a rule. That's not gameplay performance.
- Assume that the character in question is being recruited.
- Similar to the "Recruits X" rule, do not use "she brings a Savior to the team" as an argument.
- BEXP is free to be used in any quantity on any character.
- Skills can be reassigned freely.
- No transfers.
- Anyone that has done a RD RTU withholds the privilege to tell you your rating is bogus and demand you revise it if it breaks any of the above. I will not throw out votes anonymously, you will be informed and given a chance to revise.

Averages:
Fiona: 1.20
Meg: 1.34
Astrid: 2.10
Lethe: 2.21
Vika: 2.40
Leonardo: 2.53
Lucia: 3.06
Danved: 3.11
Tormod: 3.28
Brom: 3.56
Ilyana: 3.75
Makalov: 4.00
Nealuchi: 4.41
Tauroneo: 4.50
Geoffery: 4.50
Black Knight: 4.60
Maurim: 4.72
Kieran: 4.82
Aran: 4.92
Laura: 5.13
Heather: 5.29
Soren: 5.45
Edward: 6.31
Micaiah: 6.50
Calill: 6.59
Mordecai: 7.17
Marcia: 7.31
Zihark: 7.44
Nephenee: 7.74
Elincia: 8.21
Leanne: 8.38
Rafiel: 8.45
Jill: 8.46
Volug: 8.87
Sothe: 8.93
Nailah: 9.00
Nolan: 9.06
Ike: 9.28
Titania: 9.76
Haar: 9.91

Edited by Lucina, 12 June 2012 - 08:23 AM.

[Aquaman]

I attempted to use her on HM once.

Never again.

Healing isn't needed, she takes bexp AND for what?

A mounted healer?

lolHealing in fe10

0/10

One of the bunch that's better on NM.

Applying negative bias

Haha.

My score is 1/10, and apply bias and make it 0/10

Edited by Folgore Green, 12 June 2012 - 08:38 AM.

[NinjaMonkey]

Healing isn't needed

So, I take it that enemy hit-rates on HM are terrible, then?

[Samias]

You need at LEAST 3 healers, but Micaiah and Elincia already cover 2/3 with more than enough competence. Mist, on the other hand...

Pros:
+Gets a horse when she classes up

Cons:
+No more magic swords
+Sucks

Mist is just bad. Seriously. No more magic swords to even make her viable. No more bands to improve her terrible growths. Now that Elincia comes properly leveled, Mist is largely unnecessary. Like Ilyana and Astrid, Mist just took a huge beating in the generation gap, losing all the cool things that once made her valuable. Really, the ONLY thing that makes her special is her horse, because her offence sucks so bad that, if you never bexp twink her, she wouldn't even hit her strength cap of 25 . She can't even SS rank staves, either, just swords. The Florete is nowhere near as good as the Amiti either, so Mist is just an inferior Elincia with better availability.

I'd probably be more impressed if the Florete was magic/magic swords were still around, but Mist just blows this time around. If you need a healer, she's there, but Rhys is also there, Micaiah is forced, and Elincia does Mist's job, but better.

3/10, because healers are always valuable, but Mist is just... bleh. In fact, -1 bias for her stupid voice in that cutscene at the end of part 2 for 2/10.

Edited by Samias, 11 June 2012 - 09:47 PM.

[Peekayell]

Lolworthy bases. Bad growths. Terrible offense and durability. Doesnt have quite enough mag to use physic better than rhys despite better move. Shes truly horrible. She should never see combat ever as she is too fail for that. She grows at a very slow pace and horse isnt as significant an advantage in this game. Especially because shes probably not ever gonna get it. Even with favoritism, i can only see mist getting the horse in 4-4, which is terrible timing. 0/10 (-1 bias for loli)

[Zeem]

0/10 (-1 bias for loli)

Not in this game.

[Levant Fortner]

She can't even SS rank staves, either, just swords.

That's a minor point at best, considering that Matrona's pretty useless, and the Ashera Staff comes along with someone who can use it, putting aside the fact getting said person might not even be worth it IMO...

Mist just took a huge beating in the generation gap, losing all the cool things that once made her valuable.

True, she got hurt pretty bad, but I'd say Lethe suffered even more, going from decent in PoR to... what I can only describe as a joke in RD.

Edited by Golden Cucco, 11 June 2012 - 11:28 PM.

[nano]

This is day 41 I think.

Mist. At least HM wants heals more than NM, and she has mov advantage over Rhys. Combat is never salvageable, but she can get some exp from physics and Hammerne. Restore staff is also helpful in 3-E and 4-4, where she may have an advantage over Rhys. Both are ORKO'd by enemies, but she has more mov. All in all not that useful.

2.5/10 - 0.5 bias for horrible English voice acting.

[Levant Fortner]

I'll give her a 3.5. Healing may not be worth much, but it's more than what schmucks like Lethe can do.

EDit: And add a bias point because I like her redesign (and because her wielding Alondite's hilarious, but that's neither here nor there) for 4.5.

Edited by Golden Cucco, 12 June 2012 - 02:38 PM.

[Jedi]

Oh Mist, you were one of my favorite units in PoR now look at you.

Mist while having meh base stats when she arrives she has a good amount of availability don't expect to get her far in HM though, she is much more suited to NM, her speed, skill and magic are decent, she can use swords right from the get go this time.. unfortunately she doesn't have the strength to back it up, and there are no longer swords that are based off magical ability so she got nerfed BIG TIME and she is easily killed if left out in the open. If you do manage to get her promoted you'll have a decent horseback healer, but by that point. Elincia is back in your control who is much better at the sword swinging/healing mixture.


Overall 3.5/10 + 1 bias point for fond memories of her from PoR and the cool redesign she got. So make that 4.5

Edited by Jedisupersonic, 12 June 2012 - 12:56 AM.

[ポーラ]

The only thing she has going for her is her utility to heal and until she gets mounted, she is going to have a hard time keeping up with everybody else. Physic will remedy this for chapters that have enemies that cover alot of ground within every turn. Her Flourite makes her assertive for maybe taking out Mages for her good Res and getting herself protected from Miracle. As it only activates by the amount of luck that she has.



3.5/10 1+ bias because she has such a gentle voice as it is heard from her galdar singing and from Part 2-E cutscene.

Edited by アイネ, 12 June 2012 - 01:16 AM.

[Colonel M]

Honestly, I look at Mist and her uses are just limited. In a game where healing items can heal for 40 HP, Mist just looks really meh to that. Even the +1 Mov advantage isn't really enough to beat Rhys, who has the benefit of having a good range with Physic and healing for a greater amount. That leaves two other strengths for her - her affinity and her horse.

The former can be used effectively with Titania. Water is an awesome support to have with its +0.5 Atk / +1 Def (combined with Light) and the support builds rapidly. With Savior, Titania carries Mist from harm and effectively makes her into a support battery operated Hammer machine.

Next comes the horse, which is a double-edged sword. She does have the perks of extra Movement and Canto, but it comes at a cost with levels in order to achieve it. Considering Titania might be playing pocket Mist, and Mist's chances of making it to 10/1 seems bleak. To make matters worse, the horse bites her in the ass in 4-3. Ledges suck.

To be fair, though, she's still a staff user, which is more than what units like Soren have going for them.

4/10.

[Jimmy_Smith]

2nd best healer in game (beside Elincia) and she is better than Rhys in a long run IMO.

Mount healer is useful, and can save the day when you need it (heal and flee).

Leveling her is not much problem because good available and Paragon scroll (who need it beside her?)

Overall
6.5

Edited by Jimmy_Smith, 12 June 2012 - 02:21 AM.

[Aquaman]

2nd best healer in game (beside Elincia) and she is better than Rhys in a long run IMO.

Mount healer is useful, and can save the day when you need it (heal and flee).

Leveling her is not much problem because good available and Paragon scroll (who need it beside her?)

Overall
6.5

This is HM.
BEXP is kinda scarce.
Mist can't promote until 4-4.

ANd, she's on a team of Durable gods who rape everything.

Rhys>Mist due to desert being a possibility, better comvat, higher staff rank, and not being routelocked

[Levant Fortner]

Rhys>Mist due to desert being a possibility, better comvat, higher staff rank, and not being routelocked

Everything else you said made sense, but the bold... isn't that big a point in Rhys's favor.

[Aversa]

Today is Day 41, Lucina.

So Mist is lame. Her combat is lame, her defense is lame, and she dies to freaking everything ever. So does Rhys but he can at least RES tank and do damage! Mist has a low chance of promoting, because she'll likely need BEXP/babying to get there., and when she does promote she isn't much better. Her skill capacity actually goes down because of canto and sol. I guess if you get her far enough she's a more than competent healer, good for endgame, but she still has to compete with Elincia and Micaiah. She's also routelocked in Part 4. Whoopee.

Overall 2/10 for an endgame which isn't pitiful, too bad the rest of her game is.

[Jimmy_Smith]

This is HM.
BEXP is kinda scarce.
Mist can't promote until 4-4.

ANd, she's on a team of Durable gods who rape everything.

Rhys>Mist due to desert being a possibility, better comvat, higher staff rank, and not being routelocked

I didn't say about BEXP, I say give her paragon scroll.

I didn't say Mist > Rhys, I say Mist is a better healer.

Both Mist and Rhys will get S rank in staff very early, and that all they need because SS staff is for Micaiah.(You get another SS staff very late)

About Promote, They both will be promote late anyway, and Rhys at tier 2 and 3 is identical (Heal bot)

Routelocked is noting because both Mist and Rhys will go to same rout anyway, another 2 routes have Micaiah and Elincia, they don't need another healer.

Edited by Jimmy_Smith, 12 June 2012 - 07:08 AM.

[Aversa]

Routelocked is noting because both Mist and Rhys will go to same rout anyway, another 2 routes have Micaiah and Elincia, they don't need another healer.

Rhys can go desert where he can actually move. Besides, over 1 healer is always nice, there's a line of when you have "too many" healers (when your entire party is staff users, you may want to reconsider your choices).

[Shotguner159]

She can heal, can provide shitty chip and wall mages, can't promote till 4-1 - meh. If she gets an A support with Boyd we do get an extra Spirit Dust in 3-E, and it takes very little time to set up, but don't think that counts towards the scores we can give.
2/10.

[Samias]

Rhys can perform a vital chip which is sometimes more valuable than healing. Both Mist and Rhys get doubled by practically everything but if Rhys can finish off a nearby enemy, it can really pay off. Mist can't deal damage worth crap, can't take hits worth crap, and her heal is inferior for a long time. Mist is only lucky that a sucky healer is more tolerable than any other type of unit. In the GM chapters she'll be outclassing Ilyana by miles and miles...