2145 replies to this topic

[BBM]

We only get my vigshot for N6 if we lynch correctly tomorrow, even if we nolynch today.

[BBM]

"It gives us a slightly better chance at guessing correctly tomorrow, but that's it. We have to risk a mislynch at some point, whether it's this phase or the next day."

What I meant there was that while we have a slightly better chance at guessing correctly, our chances won't be better by enough for it to make much of a difference.

[Deliriyum]

What is a nolynch going to get us at this point? If we're in MYLO right now, it puts us in LYLO tomorrow, with nothing other than another dead townie.

It gives us a slightly better chance at guessing correctly tomorrow, but that's it. We have to risk a mislynch at some point, whether it's this phase or the next day.

I am against nolynching, but if we're going to do it, where is everybody going? It's vitally important that people are split up properly so that the death gets as much info as possible.

Also, guys, consider that the mafia has a protection pierce, because the Poketrio should have been immune to one attempted kill. I don't know if this pierce is a permanent role or a one-shot thing, but putting me, Core, and Person3 on a stage does not automatically mean Core is scum if I die even though he was on me.

Castle Siege: Me, BBM, SB

Brinstar: Shinori, Iris, Eclipse, Manix, Strawman

I can protect BBM, SB can do whatever, idc. The death will likely occur on Brinstar but that will probs eliminate a suspect. Manix can do something useful as well. Unless you think it would be better if I protected Manix?

I'd like it if Shinori used his ability on SB, also.

[eclipse]

Shinori, why do you avoid the PM? You can try to explain yourself there, too.

After seeing 2/3 of the people on the Halberd voting No Lynch, I'm not sure if it's a good idea. Also, where the hell is Strawman?

[Shinori]

That is a terrible set up core. Fucking hell. If scum kills iris we learn frankly nothing.

[Shinori]

Also you want me to use my ability on SB but I'm not on that stage in your setup.

[Shinori]

Can someone show me where SB posted that he has to random a stage and why he has to? I want to see that post. Because I don't think this happened at all so far in the game.

[Manix]

Seems good, but I get randomly placed according to Paper. And I can't do anything tonight remember?

here Shinori

[Manix]

It's presumably because of Straw's ability

SB was on Halberd, but it isn't a valid stage choice anymore, or something

[Serious Bananas]

No lynching could drag it out into BBM getting another vig shot, and we'd be better informed. We'd do better to wait the day out and the death in thr night should give us the information we need.

##Vote: No Lynch

[eclipse]

. . .wait, what? BBM doesn't "shoot" until N6.

Strawman, where are you?

[Serious Bananas]

Yeah, but if we pull through day 6 we can probably win.

Assuming 5:3 split here.

If we no lynch:

D5: No Lynch
N5: Doc on BBM, scum kill one. (4-3)
D6: Lynch the scummiest looking person (4-2, but if we miss here we lose)
N6: BBM shoots scum, scum get another kill (3-1)
D7: Lynch the scummiest looking one, or wait a night to narrow down choices to 2-1. Either way you have to hit.

If we lynch today, we lose if we hit a townie, unless Core is town and actually manages to block the kill. I'd rather take the option that has less risk involved tbh.

[Shinori]

Yeah, but if we pull through day 6 we can probably win.

Assuming 5:3 split here.

If we no lynch:

D5: No Lynch
N5: Doc on BBM, scum kill one. (4-3)
D6: Lynch the scummiest looking person (4-2, but if we miss here we lose)
N6: BBM shoots scum, scum get another kill (3-1)
D7: Lynch the scummiest looking one, or wait a night to narrow down choices to 2-1. Either way you have to hit.

If we lynch today, we lose if we hit a townie, unless Core is town and actually manages to block the kill. I'd rather take the option that has less risk involved tbh.

You are as scum as scum could be. Swear to god.

[eclipse]

. . .I've made up my mind. That was beyond terrible; right now, you're suspicious of Core, and you are saying that he protects someone? My apologies, Prims, but we should've lynched him back on D2.

##Unvote
##Vote: Bananas

[Serious Bananas]

I was saying if, and I said my suspicions about him at the bottom of my post. Although I was pretty stupid for factoring in a guaranteed doc in, it will be pretty hard to pull off either way.

[eclipse]

Look, either you think the doc is scum or he's not. If he's scum, then your chart was pointless. If he's not, then why are you suspicious of him?

[Serious Bananas]

I think he's scum. But he turns out not to be, then it's probably the best thing he can do for the win.

I was suspicious because of the report I got back.

Observing your first target from your star fighter, you can see that they visited Serious Bananas and Proto. They were visited by no one.

If you get this back and this doesn't scream scum, I don't know what does. And I'm pretty sure you know by now I can make some pretty stupid decisions.

[Shinori]

A lot of stuff is off in this game, SB is probably scum.

[eclipse]

By your own watcher report, he's scum, but you're saying "what if he's not"? Really? You take a side, not waffle.

[Serious Bananas]

I'm certain he's scum. But I'm not sure about the rest. Seeing as how I won't get enough votes to lynch him, I would rather no lynch then gamble the game away when we would have better odds tomorrow.