1230 replies to this topic

[Helios]

I think the fact that I knew Marth wasn't very active in general for IRL reasons affected my read on him, but like you said just about everyone's scumdars were a bit off this game. Just gotta learn and do better in the future.

[eclipse]

C'mon, I HAD THE BEST FLAVOR.

The fact that we're all screaming about it means that Prims did a good job~!

[Helios]

I think Manix had the best flavor, but I liked mine too.

[eclipse]

My only issue with the role is that disabling on both sides means that I can easily misfire, but eh. I feel this was probably the worst game I've played in a while. My apologies, Prims.

Oh gosh, this can be interpreted weirdly. Lemme clarify:

I thought my in-game play was terrible. I didn't have too much issue with the game itself.

[Kaoz]

3 points from my side, all of which were present in this game, but are also issues in general.

1) Prims already touched on this, but stop self voting, regardless of what side you're on. I applaud WoMC for keeping his policy vote on Shinori until the phase was over and wish more people had done that. This ties into a more general point of just because something worked for you once or twice, doesn't mean it can't have been shitty play and in that case you shouldn't do it again and again and justify it with "well I did it back then too".

2) Playstyles. It's true that there's no one correct playstyle for mafia (at least not right now), but that doesn't mean certain aspects of what you're doing can't be bad or "wrong". If multiple people point something out to you, or better yet do so over multiple games, then you should question what you're doing and possibly attempt to change it, otherwise you won't be getting anywhere.

3) Stop being so fucking touchy. We're not a bunch of assholes here for the most part, so don't get so upset whenever someone criticizes you.


I'm not in the mood to greatly elaborate on this, but I hope you at least grasp the gist of it.

[Tricky Dick]

3 points from my side, all of which were present in this game, but are also issues in general.

1) Prims already touched on this, but stop self voting, regardless of what side you're on. I applaud WoMC for keeping his policy vote on Shinori until the phase was over and wish more people had done that. This ties into a more general point of just because something worked for you once or twice, doesn't mean it can't have been shitty play and in that case you shouldn't do it again and again and justify it with "well I did it back then too".

2) Playstyles. It's true that there's no one correct playstyle for mafia (at least not right now), but that doesn't mean certain aspects of what you're doing can't be bad or "wrong". If multiple people point something out to you, or better yet do so over multiple games, then you should question what you're doing and possibly attempt to change it, otherwise you won't be getting anywhere.

3) Stop being so fucking touchy. We're not a bunch of assholes here for the most part, so don't get so upset whenever someone criticizes you.


I'm not in the mood to greatly elaborate on this, but I hope you at least grasp the gist of it.

Well, well, well... SOMEONE seems to have learnt from my time here.

Well done, good sir.

[Bluedoom]

Oh cool, first time I win as scum. Thanks Shinori :P

Honestly speaking the fact was most of the discussion always happened whenever I was sleeping, and whenever I could come on, there was no one to talk to in-thread. Sorry Shinori if you felt alone, you never really said much so I thought you had everything under control lol. That and I had no idea what exactly we could plan about haha( I mean we did speak about kills and stuff or N1 but after that we killed a virgin ugh)

[BBM]

Scumbuddies should be talking about more than just who they're killing at night though. They should be formulating strategies on how to look more townie, and especially they should be figuring out ways to seem townie after the flip of a scumbuddy even if they didn't bus said scumbuddy.

[Aere]

So my reads on Shinori and Marth were correct~

[WeaponsofMassConstruction]

gg everyone

I'm sorry for screwing it up the last 2 days.

[Gyarados]

You are Excellen, Town Badass (Town Virgin). You're one of the few abraisive SF mafia players who are perfectly capable of playing a good game and acting like an aggressive jerk at the same time, which is worth mad respect. According to Haze, you are also an amazing poet. Unfortunately neither of these things let you do much more than shout at people.

Abilities
Mafia of the Manly Men (Passive): Should you die, manly tears will be shed at your unjust SSBU-level early death and all killing actions during the soonest night phase after your death will fail.

You win when all threats to the town are eliminated.

Also congratulations rolling the role with a quote of the dude condescending you.

I do approve of this role.