Claire has done nothing but tunnel me all game and given no strong scum reads elsewhere, even if she thinks I'm scum she should at this point have given a strong indication on someone else by now I think? Unless she has and I've forgotten.
Players will either act the way you said or I said imo when they are new usually. Imo fleet seems like the type of person that would act the way I suggested which is why I apply this logic. It seems based on player meta from past games now I am probably correct so that's good to know.