Find & Vote sheet and analysis

[Garlyle]

I made a sheet of places and votes on Google to check how well units have ended. Since the results can only be viewed in mobile devices, I thought some people might be interested. But I'll also go with my analysis.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/19e3zecmfw2EXgdSMphqjD56IfnPvI3_rmXbDrmMvgF4/edit?usp=sharing

• Green are seasonals/legendary
• Yellow are 5* locked
• Grey are 4-5* units
• Brown are 3-4* units

An interesting note that in the Top 100 we found a couple of units who are in the 3-4* pool, but there's a very reasonable reddit post about it, I'll just post the image of that. Basically the map was fixed, and you see the same units on the starting screen if you are not scrolling, which might led people to confusion.

Spoiler

Now, after them being disqualified, let's do our analysis.

Units in the Top 100 and being in the 3-4* pool:

1. Camilla at #91 - usual Camilla crap as expected, judge it as you like. The power of this is fortunately insignificant
2. Reyson at #93 - he's new, and probably people didn't realized he got demoted yet.
3. Marth at #95 - honestly? ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
4. Soren at #98 - even bigger question mark above this than Marth. But hey, Tellius.
5. Reinhardt at #100 - well, you can't go wrong with the Rein I guess.

Have to mention the 5* units from the summoning pool

1. Surtr #9 - I'm not really surprised, though I think he's still pretty bad for the game.
2. Tibarn #10 - everybody loves Tibarn
3. Nailah #16 - the perfect Veronica counter. Yes, please.
4. Veronica #19 - as a potential free unit, strange. But she's still meta, so that's a bonus score I guess.
5. Loki #25 - besides the looks, her staff can be useful in some AR matches.

Some 5* units from the summoning pool didn't do well. From top to bottom, here they are

1. Luke - honestly, even in CYL votes he didn't do too well. Potential demote from Gen1 5* pool
2. Gray - not very exciting either. We just don't want to be pitybroken by him I'd say
3. Siegbert - do people even know he's in the game?
4. Olwen(both versions) - Rein at the top, while Olwen on the bottom. Ouch Thracia.
5. Saber - cosidering that he recently got a nice weapon refine, this is surprising a little.

But we didn't covered the least wanted seasonal units

1. Summer Frederick
2. Summer Innes
3. Dancer Ryoma
4. Summer Xander
5. Hot Springs Elise
6. Summer Elise
7. Bride Sanaki
8. New Year Takumi
9. Hot Springs Ryoma
10. Valentine Lilina

I see a lot of Fates and a lot of summer units, especially male ones. Feels bad for Lilina though.

[Ice Dragon]

7 hours ago, Garlyle said:

Now, after them being disqualified, let's do our analysis.

It would at least be worth mentioning at exactly what position each of the disqualified characters placed because the way you are framing the issue makes it seem like all of the characters on the first screen got disproportionately higher numbers of votes than they should have. Being on the first screen did little to help Bartre (163), Donnel (174), or Virion (184), for example.

[Othin]

9 minutes ago, Ice Dragon said:

It would at least be worth mentioning at exactly what position each of the disqualified characters placed because the way you are framing the issue makes it seem like all of the characters on the first screen got disproportionately higher numbers of votes than they should have. Being on the first screen did little to help Bartre (163), Donnel (174), or Virion (184), for example.

We don't know how much it did help them, but I think it's fair to suspect that it may still have given them some help.

[Ice Dragon]

12 minutes ago, Othin said:

We don't know how much it did help them, but I think it's fair to suspect that it may still have given them some help.

Which is why it should be mentioned where each of them actually placed for the several that didn't happen to make it into the top 30.

[Othin]

2 minutes ago, Ice Dragon said:

Which is why it should be mentioned where each of them actually placed for the several that didn't happen to make it into the top 30.

Makes sense.

[Tybrosion]

45 minutes ago, Ice Dragon said:

Being on the first screen did little to help Bartre (163), Donnel (174), or Virion (184), for example.

While that is true, they still all got over a 1,000 (over 1,500 for Bartre and Donnel) votes each when they (especially Virion and Donnel) all should’ve performed as poorly as characters like Hawkeye or Gwendolyn.

Also (sorry to nitpick), Bartre is 168. There is no 163 due to Hardin and Eldigan tying for 162.

[Ice Dragon]

1 minute ago, Tybrosion said:

Also (sorry to nitpick), Bartre is 168. There is no 163 due to Hardin and Eldigan tying for 162.

My eraser hand slipped and clipped off the left side of the 8.

[Anacybele]

Summer Freddy being the least wanted seasonal unit makes me sad. ;_;

But I guess I can get why he wouldn't be wanted. He doesn't have much to offer in terms of fodder or stats...

[Landmaster]

I will take all the Hostile and Summer Elises~

[Tybrosion]

For anyone curious, I grouped characters according to their introduction banner to compare how they did against the rest of their banner (* = initial screen character)

Book I Banners

Spoiler

Family Bonds
1. Ephraim: 2,668 votes, 120th
2. Julia: 2,383 votes, 133rd
3. Eirika: 2,212 votes, 142nd
4. Seliph: 1,788 votes, 166th

Sibling Bonds
1. Reinhardt: 3,298 votes, 100th
2. Eldigan: 1,808 votes, 162nd
3. Klein: 1,307 votes, 190th
4. Sanaki: 1,209 votes, 203rd
5. Olwen: 663 votes, 245th
6. Lachesis: 571 votes, 250th

Blazing Shadows
1. Ninian: 3,286 votes, 101st
2. Jaffar: 1,688 votes, 170th
3. Karel: 1,442 votes, 181st
4. Lucius: 1,132 votes, 207th
5. Rebecca: 412 votes, 265th
6. Priscilla: 356 votes, 269th

Spring Festival
1. Camilla: 5,061 votes, 69th [insert immature joke here]
2. Lucina: 3,040 votes, 108th
3. Chrom: 1,945 votes, 156th
4. Xander: 1,284 votes, 192nd

World of Shadows
1. Alm: 11,609 votes, 31st
2. Faye: 2,448 votes, 127th
3. Lukas: 1,196 votes, 204th
4. Clair: 373 votes, 268th

World of Radiance
1. Soren: 3,347 votes, 98th
2. Mist: 3,316 votes, 99th
3. Ike: 2,905 votes, 113th
4. Titania: 842 votes, 228th

Rite of Shadows
1. Celica: 4,607 votes, 75th
2. Genny: 2,991 votes, 110th
3. Mae: 481 votes, 260th
4. Boey: 347 votes, 271st

Bridal Blessings
1. Charlotte*: 8,105 votes, 41st
2. Cordelia: 5,485 votes, 64th
3. Lyn: 3,749 votes, 89th
4. Caeda: 1,653 votes, 172nd

Echoes of Mystery
1. Katarina: 1,817 votes, 161st
2. Luke: 280 votes, 277th
3. Athena: 269 votes, 278th
4. Roderick: 115 votes, 289th (dead last)
This is why Archanea hasn't gotten another banner.

Ylissean Summer
1. Robin: 4,273 votes, 79th
2. Tiki: 2,613 votes, 122nd
3. Gaius: 1,303 votes, 191st
4. Frederick: 601 votes, 247th

Alm's Army
1. Delthea: 1,946 votes, 155th
2. Gray: 438 votes, 262nd
3. Mathilda: 197 votes, 284th

Celica's Army
1. Sonya: 1,475 votes, 179th
2. Saber: 895 votes, 223rd
3. Leon: 416 votes, 264th

Nohrian Summer
1. Corrin: 4,677 votes, 72nd
2. Leo: 2,462 votes, 126th
3. Elise: 1,006 votes, 213th
4. Xander: 969 votes, 216th

The Sacred World
1. Amelia: 3,237 votes, 103rd
2. Tana: 1,347 votes, 187th
3. Innes: 1,332 votes, 189th
4. Seth: 564 votes, 251st

Brave Heroes
1. Lyn: 7,601 votes, 43rd
2. Ike: 3,985 votes, 85th
3. Roy: 3,201 votes, 105th
4. Lucina: 3,186 votes, 106th

Dauntless Crimeans
1. Nephenee*: 20,809 votes, 18th
2. Elincia: 1,790 votes, 165th
3. Oscar: 204 votes, 283rd

Performing Arts
1. Azura: 8,314 votes, 39th
2. Inigo: 3,438 votes, 94th
3. Olivia: 2,776 votes, 116th
4. Shigure: 1,584 votes, 175th

World of Holy War
1. Sigurd: 5,170 votes, 68th
2. Deirdre: 1,983 votes, 152nd
3. Tailtiu: 508 votes, 257th
Ayra wasn't on this banner, but I'll leave her results here since she was introduced alongside these guys: 9,916 votes, 34th

Trick or Defeat!
1. Jakob: 5,848 votes, 57th
2. Sakura: 4,058 votes, 81st
3. Nowi: 2,927 votes, 112th
4. Henry: 2,752 votes, 117th

Farfetched Heroes
1. Mia: 4,022 votes, 83rd
2. Lute: 2,432 votes, 128th
3. Dorcas: 940 votes, 219th

Book II Banners

Spoiler

Children of Fate
1. Soleil: 2,408 votes, 131st
2. Shiro: 1,156 votes, 206th
3. Siegbert: 591 votes, 248th
Rhajat's results, as she's the same case as Ayra: 1,388 votes, 186th

Winter's Envoy
1. Lissa*: 14,669 votes, 26th
2. Tharja: 11,547 votes, 32nd
3. Robin*: 8,604 votes, 37th
4. Chrom: 1,524 votes, 176th

Happy New Year!
1. Azura: 2,105 votes, 145th
2. Camilla: 1,405 votes, 185th
3. Takumi: 1,258 votes, 195th

World of Dawn
1. Zelgius*: 24,473 votes, 15th
2. Micaiah: 7,460 votes, 44th
3. Sothe: 1,172 votes, 205th

Sacred Memories
1. Myrrh: 7,334 votes, 45th
2. Eirika: 2,000 votes, 151st
3. L'Arachel: 527 votes, 253rd

Love Abounds
1. Hector: 5,181 votes, 67th
2. Roy: 2,900 votes, 114th
3. Lyn: 1,740 votes, 167th
4. Lilina: 1,268 votes, 193rd

Fallen Heroes
1. Robin: 14,331 votes, 27th
2. Celica: 3,284 votes, 102nd
3. Hardin: 1,808 votes, 162nd

The Branded King
1. Morgan (F): 3,828 votes, 88th
2. Chrom: 2,861 votes, 115th
3. Morgan (M): 1,251 votes, 196th

Hares at the Fair
1. Catria*: 10,916 votes, 33rd
2. Alfonse: 2,609 votes, 123rd
3. Kagero: 2,241 votes, 139th
4. Sharena: 2,037 votes, 147th

World of Thracia
1. Leif: 2,017 votes, 150th
2. Reinhardt: 1,338 votes, 188th
3. Olwen: 890 votes, 225th
4. Nanna: 336 votes, 272nd

Wings of Fate
1. Hinoka: 5,784 votes, 61st
2. Kana: 1,441 votes, 182nd
3. Shigure: 483 votes, 259th
I'd put Kaze's results here, but they're skewed since he was an initial screen character.

Genealogy
1. Isthar: 6,263 votes, 52nd
2. Ares: 1,214 votes, 201st
3. Lene: 918 votes, 222nd

Bridal Bloom
1. Ninian*: 16,379 votes, 22nd
2. Tharja: 4,657 votes, 73rd
3. Sanaki: 1,226 votes, 199th

Scattered Fangs
1. Nino: 6,465 votes, 50th
2. Karla: 2,412 votes, 130th
3. Legault: 819 votes, 230th

Summer's Arrival
1. Noire: 3,234 votes, 104th
2. Cordelia: 2,035 votes, 148th
3. Tana: 1,951 votes, 153rd
4. Innes: 798 votes, 234th

A Sketchy Summer
1. Tiki*: 25,893 votes, 14th
2. Camilla: 5,060 votes, 70th
3. Takumi: 3,519 votes, 91st
4. Linde: 2,181 votes, 143rd

Ylissean Travelers
1. Olivia: 3,991 votes, 84th
2. Maribelle: 2,152 votes, 144th
3. Sumia: 947 votes, 218th
4. Libra: 819 votes, 230th

Festival in Hoshido
1. Micaiah: 26,199 votes, 12th
2. Xander: 2,355 votes, 134th
3. Elincia: 2,086 votes, 146th
4. Ryoma: 891 votes, 224th

Arrival of the Brave
1. Veronica: 18,957 votes, 19th
2. Ephraim: 5,872 votes, 56th
3. Hector: 5,825 votes, 59th
4. Celica: 5,499 votes, 63rd

Doorway to Destiny
1. Lewyn: 12,680 votes, 28th
2. Quan: 1,802 votes, 164th
3. Silvia: 497 votes, 258th

Nohrian Dusk
1. Nina*: 16,335 votes, 23rd
2. Ophelia: 7,918 votes, 42nd
3. Flora: 3,361 votes, 97th
4. Silas: 958 votes, 217th

Generals of Muspell
1. Helbindi*: 12,315 votes, 29th
2. Laevatein: 6,804 votes, 49th
3. Laegjarn: 5,823 votes, 60th

The Land's Bounty
1. Myrrh*: 76,324 votes, 2nd
2. Mia: 15,521 votes, 24th
3. Niles: 3,138 votes, 107th
4. Kagero: 2,396 votes, 132nd

Brave Redux
1. Loki: 14,804 votes, 25th
2. Owain: 4,547 votes, 76th
3. Kliff: 4,361 votes, 77th

Adrift
1. Corrin (F): 8,510 votes, 38th
2. Camilla: 6,266 votes, 51st
3. Corrin (M): 4,249 votes, 80th
4. Mikoto: 2,590 votes, 124th

Fire and Ice
1. Surtr: 35,700 votes, 9th
2. Ylgr: 3,872 votes, 87th

Book III Banners + Legendaries, Mythics

Spoiler

Gifts of Winter
1. Fae: 7,307 votes, 46th
2. Eirika: 6,833 votes, 48th
3. Ephraim: 2,243 votes, 137th

New Year's of Fire and Ice
1. Fjorm: 5,902 votes, 54th
2. Gunnthra: 5,629 votes, 62nd
3. Hrid: 3,511 votes, 92nd
4. Laevatein: 2,242 votes, 138th

Rulers of the Laguz
1. Tibarn: 33,842 votes, 10th
2. Nailah: 23,965 votes, 16th
3. Leanne: 9,562 votes, 35th
4. Reyson: 3,505 votes, 93rd

Hostile Springs
1. Sakura: 4,651 votes, 74th
2. Hinoka: 2,711 votes, 119th
3. Ryoma: 1,265 votes, 194th
4. Elise: 993 votes, 214th

Legendaries, Mythics
1. Azura: 106,755 votes, 1st
2. Tiki: 64,607 votes, 3rd
3. Duma: 42,902 votes, 4th
4. Lyn*: 41,227 votes, 5th
5. Marth: 39,457 votes, 6th
6. Ike*: 38,254 votes, 7th
7. Hector: 38,069 votes, 8th
8. Lucina: 27,390 votes, 11th
9. Robin: 26,063 votes, 13th
10. Hrid: 22,670 votes, 17th
11. Eirika: 17,865 votes, 20th
12. Ephraim: 8,141 votes, 40th
13. Eir: 7,230 votes, 47th
14. Gunnthra: 4,318 votes, 78th
15. Ryoma: 4,031 votes, 82nd
16. Fjorm: 3,364 votes, 96th

 

[Ice Dragon]

On a complete side note, I'm proud to know that I contributed a full 1/187th of the total votes for New Year Laevatein.

[daisy jane]

as i love them both. i'm more sad people didn't want SY Tiki (who is awesome) over Myrrh (who is awesome but she's armour) :(

[Garlyle]

@Tybrosion Wow, that's an impressive analysis. Took you some time I guess, but thank you.

Also, I spotted someone in the FEH Unit Builder this morning. I wonder how they feel about her.

[jameslove001]

I know it makes me a dork, but I wasted very vote on Micaiah. I know I should be happy with my NY version of her, but man...also, it is interesting to see what everyone wants to draw. I just want Micaiah and Ephraim. Sure, there are other (and even better) units I don't have, but now that I have drawn a Hector at all, those are my two most notorious dodgers.

[Garlyle]

58 minutes ago, jameslove001 said:

I know it makes me a dork, but I wasted very vote on Micaiah. I know I should be happy with my NY version of her, but man...also, it is interesting to see what everyone wants to draw. I just want Micaiah and Ephraim. Sure, there are other (and even better) units I don't have, but now that I have drawn a Hector at all, those are my two most notorious dodgers.

It's your choice, so it's not wasted. Heck, I voted for Ayra even when I knew she doesn't have much chance to win.